Variability Analysis of the Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer against 3 Automated Cell Counting Devices and the Manual Method
Published: November 11, 2026
Key Takeaways
- The Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer demonstrated lower measurement variability than the other automated cell counting devices evaluated in this study.
- Automated sample preparation and analysis helped reduce sources of variability commonly associated with manual cell counting workflows.
- The study evaluated multiple cell suspensions, including CHO HD1, HEK Expi293 and SF9 cells, across several culture days and dilution conditions.
- The Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer combines automated sample preparation, Trypan Blue staining, imaging and analysis within a single workflow.
- Lower variability can improve confidence in cell concentration and viability measurements, supporting more reliable cell culture monitoring and bioprocessing decisions.
- Compared with manual counting methods, automated workflows can help improve measurement consistency while reducing operator-dependent variability.
- The study supports the use of the Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer for applications where reproducible cell count and viability measurements are important for process monitoring and decision-making.
Introduction
The manual cell counting method using a hemocytometer is often regarded as a trusted and reliable method. However, there are multiple key differences between manual and automated counting which can lead to unreliable results. The manual method involves several error-prone steps such as taking a precise sample, mixing with trypan blue and delivering it to the counting chamber, as well as subjective counting using a microscope and incremental counting device. Precise counts are often limited by time constraints of counting a limited number of grids before viability begins to drop off, which can lead to increased variability and reduced statistical confidence in the results. Live and dead cells must be differentiated subjectively by the operator, which can lead to inconsistent results even within the same laboratory (Salinas et al. 1997). With automated counters, the sampling and mixing steps are performed in a highly repeatable and consistent manner, and image-based counting algorithms streamline the enumeration process. The Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer offers an automated solution to manual counting. The device prepares the sample by mixing with trypan blue and automatically delivers it to the flow cell to take up to 100 images in as little as 90 seconds. It can be used with both individual tubes and 96-well plates. The device has been shown to have low instrument-to-instrument variability as described in the Evaluation of Instrument-to-Instrument Performance of the Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer application note.
In the following application note, a comparison of cell counts and viability was performed for 3 suspension cell lines on 4 different automated counting instruments from different manufacturers against the manual method using a hemocytometer. The comparison was performed by a third party and the provided raw data was analyzed with JMP 16.
The three different cell lines and medium types are listed below:
| Cell Line | Medium | Days of Culture |
|---|---|---|
| CHO K1 | CDCHO + Pen-Strep | 9 |
| HEK Exip293 | Expi293 + Pen-Strep | 7 |
| Sf9 ExpiSf9 | Sf-900 + Pen-Strep | 8 |
Table 1. Cell lines and medium types.
Measuring devices and specifications
| Method | Cell Diameter Range | Density Range | Sample volume | Analysis time | Automated Prep | Automated Counting |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| XR | 3-70μM | 5E+04 - 1E+07 | 500μL | <180 sec | Yes | Yes |
| BLU | 2-60μM | 5E+04 - 1.5E+07 | 200μL | <130 sec | Yes | Yes |
| Device 2 | 4-70μM | 1E+05 - 8E+07 | 400μL | 228 sec | Yes | Yes |
| Device 1 | NA | 1E+04 - 1E+07 | 10μL | 10 sec | No | Yes |
| Manual | NA | NA | 10μL | Variable | No | No |
Table 2. Instrument devices and specifications. Instrument settings optimizations were performed by representatives of each manufacturer.
Culturing method
Cells were taken from LN2 storage and were allowed to recover in 15mL of media over 4-6 days. Cultures were then expanded in 50mL flasks for 4-6 days. Next, 4 flasks were seeded at 0.5e6 cells/mL in 75mL of media.
Sampling method
5 mLs from each flask was taken and diluted at 10, 30, 50, 70 and 90%. For each cell type, 3-4 replicates per dilution were tested on each day for up to 9 days.
Statistical methods
Values were divided by the dilution factor to get a standardized estimated undiluted value. Viability was calculated by dividing the viable cell count by the total cell count.
Contaminated samples and samples with instrument failures during analysis were not included in statistical analyses. Clear outliers were manually removed when values were visibly off from the trend of the entire data set. For example, if a replicate was over or under ~1.5 times the mean of the replicates of the same sample. No outliers were manually removed from the manual counts due to the high spread. Values with viability readings less than 70% for days 1-6 were removed. A total of 42 outliers were removed from the data set of 2240 data points.
Variability analysis results

Figure 1. Total Cell Count (TCD).


Figure 3. Viability %.
Figures 1-3. Variability of results (up to 4 replicates) by days (7-9) and methods (5). Data was normalized to the estimated initial sample density by dividing results by the dilution factor.
Coefficient of variation for replicates expressed as a percentage (%CV): Mean results were averaged across days by cell line

Figure 4. Mean %CV results for TCD, VCD and Viability % by Method and Cell Type. CV (%) is the mean of %CV values averaged across all days for each cell type and method.
Conclusion
Values were divided by the dilution factor to get a standardized estimated undiluted value. Viability was calculated by dividing the viable cell count by the total cell count.
Based on the results presented, the Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer emerges as the optimal choice for cell counting when considering variability between measurements. Its low variability among replicates across days and cell lines, coupled with its sample run time savings, makes the Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer an invaluable tool for monitoring cell health in bioprocessing applications such as virus and antibody production.
A low replicate %CV can be beneficial to consistently determine target values without the need to run excessive replicates. For high- and medium-throughput applications, the time savings and freedom to run alternative samples in place of excessive replicates can reduce costs associated with inefficiencies. Furthermore, its low instrument-to-instrument variability solidifies its position as the go-to instrument for cell-based process monitoring when instruments are required across multiple sites. With the Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer, researchers can confidently make critical decisions based on consistent results when monitoring cell health.
References
1. Salinas, M et al. Ann Rheum Dis. Oct 1997; 56(10): 622-626. Comparison of manual and automated cell counts in EDTA preserved synovial fluids. Storage has little influence on the results.
2. Beckman Coulter. 2019. Application Note. Evaluation of Instrument-to-Instrument Performance of the Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer.
Product is not verified or validated for use in diagnostic procedures. This application note is for demonstration
only and is not validated by Beckman Coulter. Beckman Coulter makes no warranties express or implied with
respect to this application note and non-Beckman Coulter products, including warranties of fitness for a
particular purpose or merchantability or that the application note is non-infringing. Your use of the method is
solely at your own risk, without recourse to Beckman Coulter.
FAQ on the Cell Counting Variability Study
1. What was the objective of this study?
This study evaluated the variability of the Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer compared with three automated cell counting devices and a manual hemocytometer-based counting method across multiple cell lines and culture conditions.
2. Which cell counting methods were compared in this study?
The study compared the Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer, three commercially available automated cell counting devices, and a manual cell counting method to assess variability in total cell count, viable cell count and viability measurements.
3. Which cell lines were evaluated in this study?
The evaluation included CHO HD1, HEK Expi293 and SF9 suspension cell cultures. Samples were analyzed across multiple culture days and dilution conditions to compare measurement consistency between methods.
4. How did the Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer perform compared with other automated cell counting devices?
The results showed that the Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer demonstrated lower variability between measurements than the other cell counting devices evaluated in the study, supporting consistent cell count and viability analysis.
5. Why is measurement variability important in cell counting ?
Measurement variability can affect confidence in cell concentration and viability results. Lower variability helps researchers and bioprocessing teams make more informed decisions by providing more consistent and reliable data over time.
6. Can automated sample preparation reduce variability?
Yes. Automated sample preparation can help reduce variability associated with manual handling, mixing, staining and counting procedures. The Vi-CELL BLU system automates these steps to support measurement consistency.
7. What cell viability method was used by the Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer?
The Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer uses the trypan blue exclusion method together with automated imaging and analysis to determine cell concentration and viability.
8. Why was the Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer identified as the optimal choice in this study?
Based on the study results, the Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer combined low measurement variability with automated sample preparation and rapid analysis, making it a valuable tool for monitoring cell health in bioprocessing applications.
9. How does the Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer compare with manual cell counting methods?
Unlike manual hemocytometer counting, the Vi-CELL BLU Cell Viability Analyzer automates sample preparation, staining, imaging and analysis, helping reduce operator-dependent variability and improve measurement consistency.
10. What are the benefits of automated cell viability analysis?
Automated cell viability analysis can improve consistency, reduce manual handling, minimize operator variability and support more standardized cell culture workflows.